?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Hobbit Nerd - Jumping into the Void

> Recent Entries
> Archive
> Friends
> Profile
> Das Uber Page

December 24th, 2012


Previous Entry Share Next Entry
11:20 pm - Hobbit Nerd
I re-read the Hobbit in anticipation of seeing the movie (great movie by the way). On the map of Erebor showing the moon letters in the line "When the thrush knocks...", the word "when" is mispelled. It it spelled HWEN. Every other word follows normal English usage, merely substituting Runes for English/Roman letters.

The runes are the Anglo-Saxon runes. Later for the Lord of the Rings, Tolkien re-did the runes differently for the dwarfs, such that the rune normally the F rune became G for Gandalf. In the movie they show Gandalf scratching the newer Dwarvish G rune into Bilbo's door.

I will say that there are two things that I am very disappointed in the movie. First Radagast the Brown is made out to be a bumbling, filthy, addle-brained, drug using, hippy. Really? Sure he's close to nature, but does he have to have bird poop plastered on his hair and face? Really? I can see why they did this as he reported that the Necromancer (Sauron) had returned to Dol Guldur and Saruman didn't want to believe it because Radagast is "unreliable." But still, in the books it is mentioned that the wizards did do something about the Necromancer which is why Gandalf didn't make it to the Battle of the Five Armies until it was over. There was no mention of any friction between the wizards. Still it helps as a secondary sub-plot.

Second, they had stone giants who were actually made of stone, instead of just really large people throwing stones. This was uncalled for in my opinion.

(1 comment | Leave a comment)

Comments:


[User Picture]
From:vanye
Date:December 26th, 2012 06:23 pm (UTC)
(Link)
I hadn't actually remembered a mention of stone giants in the book, so ws very disappointed in the "addition" of the scene. A friend of mine who has read it far more often and recently than I said that giants were in there. I'm still disappointed in the scene. :-P The could have done without the silly "oh no, dwarves are trapped on the cliff, and on a leg,oh no!" schtick.

Other than that, excellent movie. Erebor was gorgeous. I'm looking forward to the Necromancer subplot being fleshed out, and while I was slightly disappointed to the casual portrayal of Radagast, I think it works. Just as Gandalf often subsumes himself in the harmless wanderer guise, I think that Radagast does as well. He certainly pulled out of it well enough to investigate Dul Goldur and persuade Gandalf he wasn't just eating mushrooms.

> Go to Top
LiveJournal.com